John is reluctant to obfuscate the difficulty also anywhere near this much from inside the Sherlock’s visibility. John lets Sherlock faith he could be upright, however, the guy never shuts one to doorway totally: strange decisions to have an excellent heterosexual boy, but absolutely practical to own a beneficial bisexual son that is looking for a love which have Sherlock and you will hopes Sherlock might changes his notice. Even though John can’t ever knowingly say “I am not saying homosexual” contained in this earshot off Sherlock, Sherlock does overhear John point out that to Irene during the An effective Scandal in 
Belgravia – immediately after which John tries to possess a discussion about this that have Sherlock, and is shut down.
Consider, John try prepared to destroy visitors to remain close Sherlock, thus definitely however end up being happy to cover up their sex too
Better, to begin with, Sherlock did actually extremely hate the idea of John becoming attracted to your. It’s wise John create simply date girls to keep Sherlock from getting the impression. Also, when the John made an effort to day males they’d suppose he had been in search of Sherlock, but not unfairly. It creates many sense to possess John to date females, and then he doesn’t appear to have an issue with they. (Whether or not, become fair, with John you might never be yes.) It’s easy getting bisexual men and women to live heterosexual lifestyle: many people are heterosexual and assume everyone else is also, therefore heterosexual relationships potential pop-up without needing to become looked for aside.
But as to why was not John currently unlock about this, and just why does the guy obfuscate the difficulty so you’re able to their sibling and you will Costs Murray? Well, there are hints so you’re able to even more factors on these very early blog site entries. John was called a women son before getting shipped out to Afghanistan, as well as in The unmistakeable sign of Around three we are exhibited the type away from Big Sholto, a guy exactly who John considerably admires and also some of the same unsociable properties Sherlock keeps; possibly the custodian into the John try keen on those who look emotionally wounded and you may skittish.
As well as in wide conditions, it could be not surprising when the John’s gay side came to this new fore when he was at new armed forces and you may generally enclosed by men – as well as, throughout the Indication of Three we’ll be given biggest homosexual associations to the armed forces, and Biggest Sholto in particular. As well as, brand new reveal tend to bolster more often than once one gender try important to John. In the event that John features any interest anyway to help you boys, it is far from unrealistic to trust he’d act with it during the a keen ecosystem where there have been couples available people.
By far the most advising thing, not, would be the fact John’s audience of these “I’m not gay” times is not Sherlock, even despite the fact Sherlock envision John was striking into the your in the first episode and individuals continually imagine these are typically several
So what happened in the Afghanistan? We do not discover, but it is not at all difficult to speculate. Perhaps John failed to reach work in it, in which he doesn’t know how to select. Possibly it absolutely was unrequited, in which he feels unfortunate or bitter considering unsociable guys. Possibly it was requited and you may ended defectively. Possibly the guy performed work involved however, there is tension so you can keep it magic and you can, which have merely came back throughout the battle, he isn’t really yes ideas on how to go-about being discover regarding they considering their early in the day profile and his old friends getting unusual regarding it – perhaps not a rare point in the event you come out later on in lives, and you can Costs and Harry seem to select the idea comedy. To make a joke about the indisputable fact that John is homosexual was not the absolute most sensitive and painful ecosystem they might have built in the event that John desired to turn out. Or perhaps John advised himself it had been only because people just weren’t readily available, however, he’s beginning to see maybe it was more that. Maybe the guy sometimes choose girls, and you can males need sometimes be a gift. Maybe he wishes youngsters; John appears happier adequate as he learns of Mary’s maternity inside the The unmistakeable sign of Around three. It isn’t at all strange for bisexual people to have intercourse which have guys however, merely follow matchmaking having women for that reason.
Leave a Reply